Back to top
Zalari has raised $2 million USD in a founding round led by Nyamaropa Technologies
Supreme Court

Refias Masuna v The State

SC 98/19

Case Details

Court
Supreme Court
Date
24 July 2019
Citation
SC 98/19
Neutral Citation
[2019] ZWSC 98
Outcome
unknown
Case Type
Appeal

Bench

Presiding
GARWE JA
Full Bench
GARWE JAHLATSHWAYO JAMAKONI JA
Areas of Law
Criminal lawCriminal procedureFair trial rights
Keywords
murder convictionlife imprisonmenttrial irregularitiesjudicial interventionfair trial
Tags
murderfair trialjudicial biastrial irregularities
legislation
Statutes Cited
  • N
  • o
  • s
  • t
  • a
  • t
  • u
  • t
  • e
  • s
  • w
  • e
  • r
  • e
  • c
  • i
  • t
  • e
  • d
  • i
  • n
  • t
  • h
  • i
  • s
  • j
  • u
  • d
  • g
  • m
  • e
  • n
  • t
  • .
  • T
  • h
  • e
  • c
  • a
  • s
  • e
  • w
  • a
  • s
  • d
  • e
  • c
  • i
  • d
  • e
  • d
  • e
  • n
  • t
  • i
  • r
  • e
  • l
  • y
  • o
  • n
  • c
  • o
  • m
  • m
  • o
  • n
  • l
  • a
  • w
  • p
  • r
  • i
  • n
  • c
  • i
  • p
  • l
  • e
  • s
  • o
  • f
  • p
  • r
  • o
  • c
  • e
  • d
  • u
  • r
  • a
  • l
  • f
  • a
  • i
  • r
  • n
  • e
  • s
  • s
  • a
  • n
  • d
  • j
  • u
  • d
  • i
  • c
  • i
  • a
  • l
  • b
  • i
  • a
  • s
  • .
  • #
  • #
  • #
  • O
  • T
  • H
  • E
  • R
  • A
  • U
  • T
  • H
  • O
  • R
  • I
  • T
  • I
  • E
  • S
ai analysis
Case Summary

Key Issues

  • {"issue_text":"Whether the trial judge's excessive questioning and direction to call witnesses constituted bias denying the appellant a fair trial","issue_type":"procedural","dispositive":"yes","related_facts":"Trial judge asked 115 questions during cross-examination, directed State to call witnesses it didn't intend to call"}
  • {"issue_text":"Whether the conviction for murder with actual intent was sustainable on the evidence","issue_type":"mixed","dispositive":"no","related_facts":"State conceded murder with actual intent unsustainable, suggested culpable homicide at most"}
This summary was generated by AI. Use Zalari to read the full judgment.
background
Facts of the Case

Background

The appellant, an operations manager at Manifest Security, was convicted of murder with actual intent and sentenced to life imprisonment after a shooting incident at Zulu 8 mine in Fort Rixon. The incident occurred during a dispute over mine control between Blessing Ndiweni and Wilson Nyamiwa, when the appellant allegedly fired a shot that killed one of Nyamiwa's employees.
Read the full judgment, get AI analysis, and find related cases
Open in Zalari →