THE STATE v INNOCENT CHIBAYA and COSMAS CHIRINGA and DENFORD MASIYA and SIMBARASHE MUZARARI and ROBSON MAKONI (2007) — Harare High Court | Zalari

Case Details

Court

Harare High Court

Date

1 February 2007

Citation

HH 4-2007

Neutral Citation

[2007] ZWHH 4

Outcome

unknown

Case Type

Application

Bench

Presiding

GOWORA J

Full Bench

GOWORA J

Areas of Law

Criminal ProcedureConstitutional Law

Keywords

Disclosure of EvidenceRight to Fair TrialPolice Diary LogWitness Statements

Tags

DisclosureWitness StatementsPolice DocketFair Trial

legislation

Statutes Cited

4
2
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
1
9
8
3
4
2
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
1
9
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
1
3
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
1
3
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
1
6
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
1
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
6
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
7
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
8
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
2
9
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
0
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
1
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
2
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
3
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
4
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
6
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
7
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
8
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
3
9
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
0
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
1
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
2
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
3
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
4
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
6
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
7
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
8
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
4
9
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
0
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
1
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
2
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
3
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
4
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
6
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
7
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
8
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
5
9
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
0
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
1
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
2
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
3
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
4
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
6
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
7
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
8
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
6
9
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
0
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
1
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
2
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
3
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
4
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
6
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
7
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
8
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
7
9
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
0
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
1
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
2
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
3
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
4
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
2
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
3
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
4
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
5
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
6
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
7
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
8
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
5
9
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
6
0
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
6
1
2
8
U
.
S
.
C
.
§
2
8
6
2

ai analysis

Case Summary

Key Issues

{"issue_text":"Whether the accused are entitled to the transcript of Mr. Chinamasa's trial","issue_type":"procedural","dispositive":"no","related_facts":"State refuses to provide transcript, claiming irrelevance"}
{"issue_text":"Whether the accused are entitled to witness statements from the police docket","issue_type":"law","dispositive":"no","related_facts":"Accused seek statements made by witnesses on 16 January 2006 to 15 March 2006"}
{"issue_text":"Whether the accused are entitled to police diary logs for the period 16 January 2006 to 15 March 2006","issue_type":"law","dispositive":"yes","related_facts":"Accused requested police diary logs but provided no legal basis"}

This summary was generated by AI. Use Zalari to read the full judgment.

background

Facts of the Case

Background

The accused persons, facing a charge of attempting to defeat or obstruct the course of justice, applied for disclosure of documents from the State. The State had already provided transcripts of previous proceedings but refused to provide the transcript of the trial of Mr. Chinamasa and certain witness statements and police diary logs. The court found that while the accused were entitled to witness statements subject to limitations, they were not entitled to the police diary logs as of right.

Read the full judgment, get AI analysis, and find related cases

Open in Zalari →